Skip to content

News & Events

{beginAccordion}

WELCOME KALEIGH TRACY AS THE SUGARCREEK FINANCIAL CENTER MANAGER

Please join us in welcoming, Kaleigh Tracy to the First Federal Team! Kaleigh will serve as the Financial Center Manager of our Sugarcreek office currently located at 1047 W. Main Street; Suite C.

Kaleigh comes to us with 10 years of banking experience with five in a leadership role. She graduated from Dover High School and Kent State University and resides in Dover with her husband, Chris, and their two children, Carter and Peyton. In her free time, Kaleigh enjoys reading and spending time with her family. She and her husband enjoy travelling and attending concerts, their most recent being Eric Church.

“I am excited to join the First Federal team and be able to give back to my community! It’s exciting to know that what I, and my fellow colleagues do, will impact those that live in the area that I’m from and still reside in” states Tracy. Kaleigh is also excited about the new First Federal Sugarcreek Financial Center, scheduled to open later this year at 1115 SW Cherry Ridge Drive. “I can’t wait to see how the addition of the new building will help us grow and give back even more,” stated Tracy.

Tiffany Kail, VP of Retail Banking stated “First Federal’s mission is to empower the financial well-being of our communities, one person at a time. Kaleigh will ensure we reach that mission in Sugarcreek and I am excited to work with her in her new role. I am also excited about how the new Financial Center will provide opportunities for growth as we continue to meet our customers’ needs.”  First Federal Community Bank will host a Groundbreaking Ceremony at the new site, June 14th at 8:45 a.m.

{endAccordion}

{beginAccordion}

WELCOME BRICE KARAM AND CONGRATS TO TAYLOR LEHMILLER ON HER NEW ROLE

Dover, OH –   First Federal Community Bank welcomes Brice Karam as Manager of Strategic Projects & Operational Efficiency.  Brice began his career in Banking at JP Morgan Chase where he served as a Business Analyst the past three years.  “This position plays a significant role in our ability to meet our strategic goals while maintaining our commitment to an exceptional customer experience.  We are excited about the fresh perspective Brice brings to the job” sated Greg Dorris, Senior Vice President.

“The opportunity to join First Federal was exciting to me for two main reasons. First, I will be closer to the customers that I am trying to help by being a part of a community bank. Second, I am excited to join a growing company that cares so much about the community.” Stated Karam.  Brice is a graduate of Ohio State University.  He is a huge sports fan and loves both the Buckeyes and the Browns. He recently married his wife, Alivia. And they reside in Mineral City. Brice is also a big fan of music, currently his playlist includes Luke Combs and Cody Johnson.

Taylor Lehmiller who recently served as Manager of Strategic Projects & Operational Efficiency has taken another leadership role as Electronic Banking Supervisor for the recently created department. She is a graduate of Dover High School and Malone University.  “I have had the privilege of serving in various roles during my career at First Federal and am excited to be leading the Electronic Banking Team!” stated Lehmiller.  When Taylor is not at work, you will likely find she and her husband, Lucas spending time enjoying the great outdoors with their two energetic boys Landon and Carson.

{endAccordion}

{beginAccordion}

PROMOTIONS ANNOUNCED FOR FINNELL, STEALEY AND WESTERN

We are proud to announce the promotion of Scott Finnell, Erick Stealey and Danielle Western.  Scott Finnell has been a banker for 30 years and served as First Federal’s Executive Vice President for the past 20 years as both the Chief Credit Officer and Senior Commercial Lending Officer.  During his tenure, the bank grew its commercial lending portfolio from $36 Million to $372 Million and its commercial lending team from 2 lenders to 6 lenders.  He also grew the Credit Department from one analyst to 4 analysts. Based upon the bank’s growth, it is typical at certain asset sizes to split these roles.  Scott was promoted to Executive Vice President & Chief Credit Officer to head up the expanded credit department and to ensure that the extraordinary credit culture he built continues forward with the bank’s planned growth. “Scott has exceptional credit talent which is evident in our outstanding credit statistics,” said Trent Troyer, President & CEO. “He has been and will continue to be a strategic partner in the bank’s growth going forward, and I am certain he will continue to excel in this new role.”  Scott and his wife Amy reside in Dover, OH.  They have three adult children Josie, Emily, and David. He earned his Bachelor of Arts Degree from Mount Union College and his MBA from Ashland University.  He currently serves on the Dover City Schools Education Foundation, City of Dover Architectural Review Committee, Board of Directors of the Rainbow Connection, Business Park Incubator, and is a Member of Dover-New Phila Kiwanis Club and Dover Tornado Club.

Erick Stealey was promoted to Senior Credit Analyst, Loan Process Administrator.  Erick is a 2003 Dover Graduate.  He and his wife (Catlin) and 3 children (Ellie, Ryder, and Theodore) reside in Canton, Ohio. Erick continued his education first at Stark State College and then at Franklin University where he completed a double Bachelor’s in Accounting and Marketing in 2009. He worked at Huntington National Bank in New Philadelphia prior to coming to First Federal in 2010. He first served as the Head Teller for our Boulevard location, and then moved to the Loan Department as a Credit Analyst soon after coming aboard. Along with his responsibilities of being a Credit Analyst, he also maintains and creates various management and tracking reports. He also is a 2014 Graduate of Leadership Tuscarawas. Erick enjoys going boating on Lake Erie and taking his family to baseball games, as he is a Cleveland Indians enthusiast as well as a season ticket holder for the Akron RubberDucks. Erick is an avid bowler and has recorded several 300 games.  Scott Finnell noted, “Erick’s knowledge of credit and technical skills have been invaluable to us as we closely monitor the loan portfolio and continue to meet ever changing and expanding loan review requirements.”

Danielle Western was promoted to Senior Credit Analyst, Credit Process Coordinator.  She began her career with First Federal in March of 2016 as a teller at the Berlin Banking Center. “Danielle has excelled as an analyst in the Credit Department since 2017,” said Finnell.  “Her ability to multitask and produce accurate results have been an incredible benefit to our lenders and entire credit review function.” Danielle graduated from New Philadelphia High School in 2010 and furthered her education and basketball career at Notre Dame College where she graduated with a Bachelor of Arts in Business Management and Marketing in 2014. Danielle has been married to her husband Robert since October 2014. She is an extremely proud mom to their son, Deacon, who turned 4 in August. Danielle also has a dog, Heisman, and a cat, Mayfield, who are big parts of the family. Danielle holds an OHSAA Girls Basketball State Record for “Most Consecutive Free Throws Made” with 54.

{endAccordion}

{beginAccordion}

MATT MILLER IS PROMOTED AND MATT KINSEY JOINS THE COMMERCIAL LENDING TEAM

We are proud to announce the promotion of Matt Miller to Senior Vice President and Chief Lending Officer. Matt’s banking career began in 2004.  He joined the First Federal team as a Commercial Loan Officer in 2009.   During that time, Matt has served as a strong advocate for businesses in our Holmes county market.  He is a graduate of Hiland High School and the College of Wooster. In 2014, Matt graduated from the Ohio Banker’s League “Bank Leadership Institute”. Matt and his wife Jen and their three children reside in Baltic, OH.  He will continue to manage his current customer portfolio while assuming leadership of the Commercial Lending Team which consists of; Kris Kreinbihl, Scott Heil, Matt Stein, Kenny Miller and the newest addition, Matt Kinsey. Matt Miller will be relocating to The First Federal Community Bank Operations & Financial Education Center on Ohio Avenue, Dover, OH upon completion late summer, 2021. 

In addition to having another record loan production year,our Commercial Lending Team provided over $60 Million in SBA PPP funding to 600 local businesses this past year. This accomplishment coupled with our passionate commitment to exceptional service has placed us near the top of all market share in both Tuscarawas and Holmes counties. “Our Commercial Team has had a strong year, and I am confident Matt Miller will continue to provide leadership, strength and direction,” said Trent Troyer, President & CEO. 

We are pleased to announce the addition of Matt Kinsey to our team as well.  He comes to us with more than 16 years’ experience writing commercial property and casualty insurance while employed at Pipes Insurance, New Philadelphia, OH.  “Matt’s extensive experience calling on, servicing, and interacting with business owners in our community provides Matt with an excellent set of skills to begin his banking career,” said Matt Miller. “Matt Kinseyjoined our commercial team, April 5, 2021 and will be focused on developing relationships in Tuscarawas and surrounding counties.”

{endAccordion}

{beginAccordion}

WE ARE GREAT PLACE TO WORK CERTIFIED

Dover, OH –   First Federal Community Bank announced that it is again Great Place to Work-Certified™ for 2021. This is the second year the bank has earned this prestigious certification.  Certification is a significant achievement that uses validated employee feedback gathered with Great Place to Work’s rigorous, data driven For All methodology. Great Place to Work is the global authority on workplace culture, employee experience and the leadership behaviors proven to deliver market-leading revenue and increased innovation.

“We are again thrilled to be Great Place to Work-Certified™,” says Trent Troyer, President & CEO.  “Our people truly make this bank great and we are excited about the ongoing construction on our Financial Education and Operations Center which will allow us to continue expanding our staff to serve our community. We are presently seeking to fill 8 new positions in advance of construction completion.” (Learn More)

“We congratulate First Federal Community Bank, on their Certification,” said Sarah Lewis-Kulin, Vice President of Best Workplace List Research at Great Place to Work. “Organizations that earn their employees’ trust create great workplace cultures that deliver outstanding business results.”

Great Place to Work® is the global authority on workplace culture. Since 1992, they have surveyed more than 100 million employees around the world and used those deep insights to define what makes a great workplace: trust. Great Place to Work helps organizations quantify their culture and produce better business results by creating a high-trust work experience for all employees. Emprising®, their culture management platform, empowers leaders with the surveys, real-time reporting, and insights they need to make data-driven people decisions. Their unparalleled benchmark data is used to recognize Great Place to Work-Certified™ companies and the Best Workplaces™ in the US and more than 60 countries, including the 100 Best Companies to Work For® and World’s Best list published annually in Fortune. Everything they do is driven by the mission to build a better world by helping every organization become a Great Place to Work For All™.

To learn more, visit greatplacetowork.com, listen to the podcast Better by Great Place to Work, and read “A Great Place to Work for All.” Join the community on LinkedInTwitter, and Instagram.

{endAccordion}

{beginAccordion}

FIRST FEDERAL COMMUNITY BANK BEGINS CONSTRUCTION FOR 8TH OFFICE AND FINANCIAL EDUCATION CENTER

First Federal Community Bank is pleased to announce construction is scheduled to begin August 3, 2020 following the official Groundbreaking held July 15, 2020 on the First Federal Financial Education & Operations Center to be located at the corner of North Wooster Ave. and West Ohio Ave. in the north end of Dover. The campus will include our 8th banking facility, office space for bank operations, and a large space to accommodate bank and community financial education, professional development, and training events. 

First Federal partnered with K-4 Architects to complete a multi-level design which consists of brick, stone and metal features.  Benchmark Construction was awarded the General Contractor bid and they will utilize as many local contractors as possible during the construction of the facility. Construction is anticipated to take 12 months with a late summer 2021 opening.

“122 Years Ago, in 1898 the Dover Building and Loan Company was founded by citizens who wanted to have a profound impact on the economic well- being of a small but growing Canal Dover Ohio area.  Although they may not have articulated it the same way, the spirit of their endeavor and our mission remain the same “TO EMPOWER THE FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF OUR COMMUNITY ONE PERSON OR BUSINESS AT A TIME”, remarked First Federal Community Bank, President & CEO, Trent Troyer.  

In December, 2019, First Federal became one of only a few Ohio Banks to be certified as a Great Place to Work, and this facility will help the bank continue to recruit and retain great employees with a passion to empower the financial needs of our community. The building will have the most current technology, a significant amount of natural light, huddle spaces for collaboration, state of the art employee gathering areas, as well as staff wellness space. 

FIRST FEDERAL COMMUNITY BANK ANNOUNCES 8TH OFFICE AND FINANCIAL EDUCATION CENTER

First Federal Community Bank is pleased to announce plans to begin construction this spring on the First Federal Financial Education & Operations Center to be located at the corner of North Wooster Ave. and West Ohio Ave. in the north end of Dover. The campus will include our 8th banking facility, office space for bank operations, and a large space to accommodate bank and community financial education, professional development, and training events. We’re also planning to have available two additional tenant spaces on the site.

The First Federal building will consist of a combination of brick, stone and metal features. Construction is anticipated to take 9 to 12 months with a spring 2021 opening. First Federal intends to use as many local contractors as possible during the construction of the facility.

First Federal recently was certified as a Great Place to Work, and this facility will help the bank continue to recruit and retain great employees with a passion to empower the financial needs of our community. The building will have the most current technology, a significant amount of natural light, huddle spaces for collaboration, state of the art employee gathering areas, as well as staff wellness space.

First Federal was founded in March of 1898 as the Dover Building and Loan Company of Canal Dover, Ohio by citizens and business people who envisioned a need for a local bank to serve the financial needs of the community. The bank has had several name changes to reflect its evolving business throughout the past 122 years as it has grown to serve our communities. We now have offices in two counties, Tuscarawas and Holmes, and continue to see growth opportunities as we position this facility to serve us for many years to come.

{endAccordion}